Toxic waste flows out of Vedanta refinery, but the news doesn't

Vedanta refinery
The alumina refinery hit the headlines last year when the nearby Dongria Kondh tribe led a successful international campaign to block the associated mining project that would have destroyed them.

Vedanta must be the best in the business when it comes to when it comes to managing the media. Either they are successfully able to block news from trickling out, or they can control what appears in the media. Quite often it is a combination of the two. 

It is, therefore, hardly surprising that reports of a recent toxic waste leak from Vedanta Aluminium Ltd’s Lanjigarh alumina refinery into a nearby river made no headlines in major news outlets in India. The Vedanta-Cairn deal, however, has been big news for a while now. 

On May 18, the India Real Time blog of the Wall Street Journal reported that a pond storing waste from the Vedanta refinery had started overflowing into a nearby river after heavy rains in Lanjigarh. The spillage of thick red waste, known as red mud, apparently continued for about an hour until Vedanta officials repaired the wall of the pond, it quoted filmmaker and activist Samarendra Das as saying.

The river that was polluted is the Vamsadhara, which flows from Lanjigarh into the Bay of Bengal in Andhra Pradesh. It is the source of water for drinking, bathing and washing for locals. Breaches in the Lanjigarh refinery pond is alleged to be a regular phenomenon.

Vedanta issued a flat denial:

On the 16th May, a heavy thunderstorm struck Lanjigarh, Orissa. Red Mud waste from the refinery is stored in a Red Mud Pond which is an earthen pond with sloping dyke walls with a base of 40 M wide and height of about 30M. Work to increase the height of the walls has been ongoing for the last six months.

During the rainstorm, the heavy rain caused loose earth from the construction area and the sloping sides to be washed into a local pond. At no time, did the Red Mud waste overflow the dyke–the discoloration in the local pond was due to the natural orangish colour of the clay earth from which the dyke is constructed.

This video, however, contradicts the Vedanta statement.

Earlier in April, toxic slurry reportedly poured out of a crack in the retaining wall into the nearby streams. It was several hours before Vedanta staff were able to stem the flow. Vedanta denied the leak, attributing the red sludge to ‘construction soil’ mixing with rainwater near to the reservoir. Survival International had issued a press release at that time. Not many, obviously, followed it up.

See this video on the April leak:

Vedanta’s flagrant flouting of environment laws and its utter disregard for the local Dongria-Kondhs had remained one of India’s most blacked-out stories for a long time. Till, of course, the Union Ministry of environment and Forests last year withdrew forest clearance for mining and stopped refinery expansion.

That had been the only time when Vedanta got its negative media coverage. Thereafter, the story has hardly been followed up by the Indian mainstream media. Hardly, being the operative word. You wouldn’t expect the Wall Street Journal to be carrying the story of the toxic sludge leak. But it did, and therein probably lies another story.